Member’s Mark Wild Caught North Atlantic Cold Water Lobster Tails, Frozen, 4 ct., priced per pound

25 reviews for Member’s Mark Wild Caught North Atlantic Cold Water Lobster Tails, Frozen, 4 ct., priced per pound

1. 

   Mason

   Rated 4 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Very satisfied

   The lobster tail came out very good. I was but nervous because it was frozen wasn't sure how the quality would taste but for the price of four tails, ...More

   The lobster tail came out very good. I was but nervous because it was frozen wasn't sure how the quality would taste but for the price of four tails, its def worth trying. As long as you cook it right, I highly recommend giving it a try.

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 4 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Really good

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 4 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   The price is good, but the lobster tails are a bit small. After grilling, they were a bit tough as well. Still edible and worth the price.

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 4 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   I ordered this a few years ago and they were the sweetest lobster tail I've ever tasted. This time they were good in texture but not super sweet. Stil...More

   I ordered this a few years ago and they were the sweetest lobster tail I've ever tasted. This time they were good in texture but not super sweet. Still, it's my once-a-year treat and I'm going to keep it! A quick broil with melted lemon butter and YUM.

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 4 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Lobster my way

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 4 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Very good, but I like Cold Water Lobster more.

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 4 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Live lobster is always the best

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 4 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   We bought the cold water lobster tails. They did taste good but it was very difficult to get the lobster meat out of the shell. We prefer the lobster ...More

   We bought the cold water lobster tails. They did taste good but it was very difficult to get the lobster meat out of the shell. We prefer the lobster tails we used to buy that were larger and the lobster meat was easier to remove from the shell.

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   OMG!!! So good albeit a little small but tasty

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Very good tasting lobster

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Great small lobster for surf and turf dinners on the grill!

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   The lobster tails were tender and had a very delicate and delicious flavor. I will definitely buy again!

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   These are great as long as you cook them properly, i prefer steaming but grilling is also good. Better price and product than the local grocery store

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   We made lobster rolls with top cut buns ,The meat was very tasty , you need a good pair of scissors to help with the removal of the meat , Cutting bot...More

   We made lobster rolls with top cut buns ,The meat was very tasty , you need a good pair of scissors to help with the removal of the meat , Cutting both the front and back .Depending on if you are making boston or New England style rolls, they will make 3 or 4 lobster rolls easly

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Well, worth the money, but I guarantee it something this good Sam’s will get rid of to get something with less or quality that they have the Walmart m...More

   Well, worth the money, but I guarantee it something this good Sam’s will get rid of to get something with less or quality that they have the Walmart mind

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Had them for dinner w/steak. We steamed them and served w/lemon & melted butter. Delicious!! As good as you get in a fancy restaurant for much les...More

   Had them for dinner w/steak. We steamed them and served w/lemon & melted butter. Delicious!! As good as you get in a fancy restaurant for much less cost. Will definitely buy again!!

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Fair price (priced per pound on each package). Excellent quality. Thawed overnight in refrigerator then removed from shells to broil. Could be staged ...More

   Fair price (priced per pound on each package). Excellent quality. Thawed overnight in refrigerator then removed from shells to broil. Could be staged on top of shells as well, if you want that for presentation. Size of each tail was perfect for individual servings.

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Excellent value! The quality seems better because the lobster tails are still frozen. Other retailers sell lobster tails that are “previously frozen” ...More

   Excellent value! The quality seems better because the lobster tails are still frozen. Other retailers sell lobster tails that are “previously frozen” and the thawed before being sold. I prefer to keep these tails frozen until the day before I cook them- then they taste very fresh!

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Excellent! My husband loved it. We used the recipe on the back for lobster rolls. He didn’t use old bay or Cyrene pepper. ( not his taste) it was east...More

   Excellent! My husband loved it. We used the recipe on the back for lobster rolls. He didn’t use old bay or Cyrene pepper. ( not his taste) it was east to take the frozen lobster tails and freeze pack them individually for single use.

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Lobster turned out great in air fryer 400 degrees 11 to 12 minutes after cutting shell and pulling out meat. These lobsters a little smaller than prev...More

   Lobster turned out great in air fryer 400 degrees 11 to 12 minutes after cutting shell and pulling out meat. These lobsters a little smaller than previous ones from Sam’s. They were packaged meat side down instead of up like previous purchases. I would not have bought them if I knew they were so small in meat size. However small, they tasted fantastic. I will stick with the larger warm water ones in future instead of the smaller cold water lobster.

   Helpful? 0 0
   Customer

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 4, 2026

   Lobster can be rather pricey, but if you are like me, you just have to spend the money. The lobster was really good. The meat had the right texture wh...More

   Lobster can be rather pricey, but if you are like me, you just have to spend the money. The lobster was really good. The meat had the right texture which is good especially since it was previously frozen. Definitely a big hit at our family cookout.

   Helpful? 0 0
   

   Olivia

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 3, 2026

   Delicious flavour

   After cooking the lobster it was delicious

   Helpful? 0 0
   

   Harper

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 2, 2026

   Delicious flavour

   After cooking the lobster it was delicious

   Helpful? 0 0
   

   Logan

   Rated 5 out of 5

   June 1, 2026

   Very satisfied

   Love it

   Helpful? 0 0
   Avery

   Rated 5 out of 5

   May 31, 2026

   Very satisfied

   Taste was excellent

   Helpful? 0 0